Now Booking for 2026 Graduations • 2 Week Notice Required

Sweet Treats for Big Moments

From custom cupcakes to signature cookie cakes, everything is baked fresh in Peebles, Ohio.

Start Your Order

The Display Case

Recent bakes for the Peebles community

Cupcakes

Signature chocolate chip cookie cake with purple rosette piping for a 13th birthday in Peebles Ohio

Cookie Cakes

Hand-piped floral birthday cake with red and yellow rosettes, fairy toppers, and ladybug details baked in Peebles Ohio

Custom Cakes

Meet the Baker

Hi! I’m Jackie. To me, the name Baked With Love by Jackie isn't just a label—it’s a promise. As an artist and piano player, I’ve always poured my heart into everything I create. Now, as I prepare to graduate from high school here in Peebles, I’m pouring that same love into custom cakes. I treat every cake like a piece of art, ensuring that the 'love' in my business name shows up in every hand-piped detail and sketched design.

The Flavor Library

Hand-crafted combinations for every palate

Classics

Reese's®
S'mores
German Chocolate
Vanilla with Nutella®
Payday®

Fresh & Fruity

Orange Creamsicle
Strawberry Lemonade
Raspberry Lemonade
Key Lime
Strawberry Shortcake

Signature

Chai
Matcha
Andes® Mint
Chocolate Ice Cream Crunch
Turtle Caramel Pecan

Pricing Guide

Quality ingredients baked fresh for every order

Cupcakes (6-pack) $12.00
Individual Cupcake $2.00 each
12 Cupcakes $24.00+
Cookies (Bag of 2) $1.50 per bag
Signature Cookie Cakes $20.00
Cake Pops $1.50 each
Custom Cakes (Single Tier) $45.00+

*Pricing may vary based on decoration and specialty flavor.

Select Your Sweets

Browse our flavor library to find the perfect combination for your event.

Customize Your Design

Let us know what you are celebrating. We will tailor the colors and decorations to match your occasion perfectly.

Schedule Your Pickup

Every order is baked fresh just for you. Secure your pickup date with a minimum 2-week notice.

Ready to order?

Email Jackie

Please note: All orders require a minimum 2-week notice.